Pizza & Sandwiches

New York Style Hand-Crafted Pizza

New York-style:Thin crust, house-made pizza sauce & mozzarella.
(12” Medium/14” Large/16” X-large)
Create-your-own - 8.99, 9.99 ,11.99
Toppings -1.49 ,1.69, 1.99
Deluxe-14.99, 16.99 ,19.99


Sicilian Thick Pan

Rectangular, thick crust, olive oil & Romano cheese crust

                                 Personal       Sharing
                              (serves 1-2)    (serves 3-4)

Create your own             7.99             13.99

Toppings                       1.29             1.69

Thin pan Deluxe+         13.99            19.99

Chicago Deep Dish

Authentic Chicago-style, corn meal crust, house-made pizza sauce & Mozzarella. (Cooking times longer than standard pizzas.)

                                Personal      Sharing
                             (serves 1-2)  (serves 3-4)

Create your own            6.99             12.99

Toppings                      0.29             1.29

Thin pan Deluxe+           9.99           17.99

‡Deluxe Toppings: Italian sausage, pepperoni, ham, mushrooms, green peppers and onions.

Pizza Toppings: Gorgonzola, Fresh Mozzarella (extra charge), Fresh Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Ham, Meatballs, Salami, Chicken, Bacon, Mushrooms, Green Pepper, Onions, Roasted Garlic, Sun-dried Tomatoes, Fresh Basil, Broccoli, Roasted Peppers, Black Olives, Green Olives, Artichoke Hearts, Pepperoncini, Pineapple, Deluxe Toppings

Specialty Pizzas (New York Style): (12”/14”/16”)

Blt: Bacon, Lettuce, Diced Tomatoes, Special Sauce And Mozzarella Cheese - 10.99,12.49,13.99


Margherita: Garlic Butter, Tomatoes, House-made Mozzarella, Fresh Basil, Balsamic Glaze.-9.99,11.49,12.99
Chicken Alfredo: Roasted Chicken Breast, Alfredo Sauce, Mozzarella.-11.99,13.49,14.99


Goodfellow’s Special-10.99,12.49,13.99

Gluten Free Crust Available 10” Only - Add 1.00 To 12” Price.
Dairy Free Cheese Available – Add 2.00


House-made Garlic Breadsticks.....4.50
Cheese Breadstick.....5.99
With Basil Pesto..add 1.99




Rosemary Chicken Sandwich 8.99

Rosemary marinated breast of chicken pan-roasted and served on a homemade roll. With Fontina cheese, red pepper mayonnaise, lettuce and tomatoes. Fries.

Oven Baked Grinder 8.99

Ham, salami, capicola, Mozzarella, Italian seasonings on French bread and oven-roasted. Fries.